82 Comments
User's avatar
Andrei Atanasov's avatar

This has real Poe vibes, and I love that from you, man!

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Thanks, Andrei. I think there's a fair raft of things swirling around in my head at the moment, literary-wise. A constant cocktail that still needs to be distilled through these experiments. Appreciate you reading, buddy.

Expand full comment
Sharron Bassano's avatar

I agree. Especially in the repetition of the hangman's lament...

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

Fascinating, and scary. I assumrd the face of the hangman would be yours.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Thanks, Terry! Appreciate you reading.

I wasn't sure how ambiguous to make that...

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

Ambiguity is your friend. It leaves the door ooen to further bifurcations in the story, should you want them

Expand full comment
Daniel Appleton's avatar

I hear the Twilight Zone theme playing in the background. Very appropriate for this scene. X - FILES ? 🔮<--- NOT MANY emojis depicting mystery mysterious or eerie.....

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Appropriate emoji. ;)

The X-Files theme is such a key part of my childhood. It still sends shivers down my spine.

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

True.

Expand full comment
Daniel Appleton's avatar

Have you seen the original TZ episode based on an Ambrose Bierce story ( which was not written as a TZ episode BTW ) ? This reminds me of that adaptation, KIND OF.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

(If Lor makes it here, I'm sure she has...)

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

I belive so. You mean incident on a bridge?

Expand full comment
Daniel Appleton's avatar

Aye, that's it. I believe that it was done in the 50s, but don't quote me.....

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

I won't. But I don't recall it as a TZ episode. I saw this in a literature class:

https://youtu.be/Mj8AlanAfUw?si=3Ewvnjq3jxPMwKEO

Expand full comment
Daniel Appleton's avatar

You've woven an interesting tapestry here. C. G. Jung would probably say that it has dreamlike imagery. I've had similar dream imagery.

Forget JUNG ! A shaman would love this. FROM ANY CULTURE.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Hehe, thanks Daniel! Weaving an interesting tapestry is always my goal.

Expand full comment
Daniel Appleton's avatar

Rod Serling told me to give you a TON of UPVOTES if possible !

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

How kind of Rod. If you're able to somehow speak to him beyond the veil then send him my thanks.

Expand full comment
Daniel Appleton's avatar

actually, it's time travel. He died of complications from lung cancer, emphysema, or both. He said he'd stop smoking if I STOPPED DRINKING, SHROOMING & USING THC. GAH !!

Expand full comment
Daniel O’Donnell's avatar

Loved this Nathan. Now, I’m maybe not as well read as some of the other commentators on here, but this brought to mind the finest type of horror fiction. It’s not gory or actually horrific in any way, yet it has that sense of unreality, of a step through the veil into something or somewhere that we are not meant to see in our daily lives. Another world that perhaps exists alongside ours and carries the weight of past horrors. See, there’s that word again 🤔😁

Think that vision of the hangman continually repeating his unrelenting mantra and begging the night for forgiveness will stay with me for a while. Brilliantly done my friend 👏

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Oh wow, thank you, Dan. To elicit such a feeling is more than I could have hoped for. It is my favourite type of horror, too. And don't worry, I have much respect for how well read you are. :)

Expand full comment
Sharron Bassano's avatar

"I wrote this semi-consciously, its meaning buried and blurred. Extract from it whatever means the most to you. Leave the rest for the hangman." Thanks for this "confession", Nathan. You have some fascinating bits here. They seem to be parts of two or three different stories in one. I want to hear them all! By the way, I personally, would like to see the photo at the head of the story rather than presented as an afterthought. I think it would be a hook that adds focus?

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Thanks Sharron. I think I used to do that, but then started shifting to the end. But you're right, it can really help to set the tone and focus. I will definitely consider doing so moving forward.

And yes, there's a lot going on here, perhaps too much crammed into too short a space, but at least it gives me something to perhaps come back to one day.

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

I agree.

Expand full comment
Susie Mawhinney's avatar

My dear departed mum, a great reader of Edgar Allen Poe who loved the macabre, the inexplicable of a mystery, saw ghosts everywhere. She had difficulty persuading my very down-to-earth, no grey father but to us, her three girls she would recount her sightings in glorious gory detail while we sat, our hearts pounding, almost out of our chests or so it seemed, shrieking and clinging to her side. To this day I don't know which were true and which were a fabric of her rich imagination!

Nathan, this story could have fallen from her mouth, I love the addition of the ants' mandibular jaws - 'mandibular' always a word that conjures a certain dread and this line, "Dawn had almost arrived, the sun still a coward behind the rise but probing the sky with its infinite rays." as if the sun too were fearful....

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

I think that's a nice mystery to remain within. I have no doubt your mother was a wondrous wordsmith and weaver of tales, but based on what you've said before then I have no doubt she was also highly attuned to things -- more so than most.

Perhaps, in some way, our discussions of her in a previous post has somehow imparted her wisdom into me and that is what led me to this story.

Expand full comment
Susie Mawhinney's avatar

I love that thought Nathan, perhaps she read our conversation!

Expand full comment
Tarik James's avatar

I've often wondered how it must have felt to be the subject scheduled to be hanged, knowing your own fate, walking in the footsteps of so many that had come and gone before. Your story spoke to that morbid and haunting curiosity. Nice work Slake. I really enjoyed your reading as well.

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

Ive often wondered how it must have felt to be the hangman

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Me too. A horrible position to be in.

Thanks so much, Tarik!

Expand full comment
Kimberly Warner's avatar

Wowza. This entire story is wildly layered and complex, I want to go back and read both parts now in one sitting….and yet despite the tangled timelines, it’s very much tethered to this wonderful immediacy of the hill, the ants, “life marching on” —the past and the present. I love how the gallows offers a place a reckoning, where your protagonist wrestles with his own sentencing, whether it’s his youth, his ability to connect, or even his sense of self.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

(if you do, perhaps it's all broken and doesn't flow together, haha.)

Thanks so much, Kimberly. Love your thoughts as always.

I just mentioned to Silvio that I feel this could, in some way (perhaps with tweaks) be a backstory segment of The Sernox, part of the protagonist's earlier years, before things descend further.

Expand full comment
Kimberly Warner's avatar

Omygod, YES!

Expand full comment
Kathleen Clare Waller's avatar

Maybe your semiconscious writing is actually more deeply conscious! I know what you mean though - like the words and thoughts come from some other place. Love the way you kept repeating this line: “Many have I hanged. Heavy is the heart that has hanged.” It is a brave thing to do, to say it over and over. It works here — building the weight of the man’s deeds and ominously calling out to the narrator. Always enjoy searching for versions of reality in your work, Nathan!

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Thanks, Kate. Love your thoughts. Did you see Nick's comment on that quote vs trimming it so it doesn't have the "that has hanged". I really like that he offered that critique up. I think, though, that this version is still the one that works in my head, but I can see how someone may read the flow differently.

The repetition for me served as a means of showing obsession by the hangman and a total solitude that he was within.

There are some fragments of truth within this piece. The name of the hill on my undergrad campus, for one.

Expand full comment
Kathleen Clare Waller's avatar

Oh nice, I meant even like “what is reality?” And the consciousness of the reader. But even better when there are layers of your experience/life. As long as you weren’t at the gallows!! :)

It’s great when comments help you push your writing forward. In this case, I agree with your original version. Your version personifies the heart. Also, instead of going for the most concise, it adds a clunky aspect that mirrors the mind of the hangman.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Spoken like a true scholar, Kate. Thank you. 😁🙏

(And no gallows, thankfully.)

Expand full comment
Silvio Castelletti's avatar

What a marvellous sequel, Nathan. I won't call it a finale, as you and I both know that no such thing exists. I savored every word. This, I just restacked, but I want to highlight it in here too: "For some days I tried to piece together what I had seen, trying to link the feelings spoken by the girl whose surname was a medieval tune, of the hangman whose voice repeated over and over, and of my heart, locked and incapable of beating its own blood, the organ in my chest I had extracted and offered on my palm to find it containing nothing but sunken valves. I couldn't piece it together. I still can't." -- words fail me.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Thanks as always for your open and lovely words, Silvio. Yes, I appreciate that we both know that something isn't necessarily a finale. I'm still wondering whether this is part of The Sernox, a flashback to years earlier in the protagonist's life. If that's so then a few tweaks would need to be made, but I'm open to the idea if/when I come back to that story.

I wrote some of this one in a disjointed order and then moved the pieces around. This part that you quote was one that helped me sit within the piece and allow the semi-conscious writing to continue.

Expand full comment
Silvio Castelletti's avatar

I really liked that one. And your possible connection to The Sernox is interesting. I look forward to seeing you trying it out. :)

Expand full comment
Ann Collins's avatar

This is like walking around in a Surrealist painting . . . so weird and dreamy. I like how you foreshadowed the hungry ants (Yikes!)

Expand full comment
Daniel Appleton's avatar

I get a very agreeably SPOOKY VIBE. Jung approves. As does Rod Serling.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Hehe, glad to hear it Daniel!

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

I love this. A walk through a Surrealist painting via words. Thanks, Ann!

Expand full comment
Alexander Ipfelkofer's avatar

“The Hat and the girl whose name was an old English folksong” love that, also would make a great title! This a marvelous conclusion to the first part. Heavy is the heart that now it is concluded.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Thanks mate! Thanks for reading. 🤗

Expand full comment
Mr. Troy Ford's avatar

Utterly chilling, Nathan - I'm reaching for a blanket to hide under... 👻

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Hehe, hope the blanket was a sufficient covering.

There’ll be something more wholesome from me this week, I think/hope!

Expand full comment
Lor's avatar

He may not have occupied the same space in time, but he momentarily, or perchance it was an eternity, accidentally slipped through the veil when he climbed the hill that day, and visited a place called Hell. Where all good hangmen are put out to pasture.

“Extract from it whatever means the most to you. Leave the rest for the hangman.”

And so I did.

One more gory part of a hanging, petechial hemorrhages of the conjunctiva. ( I thought you would appreciate the medical terminology 😊).

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

"petechial hemorrhages of the conjunctiva" -- I had to Google this to check. Very good usage. Full marks. I approve. ;)

Thank you for extracting what was necessary here. I know this probably didn't end up where most people thought (or wanted) it might go, but, well... it ended up where the story wanted to go.

Expand full comment
Lor's avatar

Then it’s a good thing I never let comments influence my enjoyment of the story.

(From movies that I have watched, I knew the capillaries in the eyes popped, of course I had to look it up too).

Expand full comment
Chris Jonah's avatar

Firstly, brilliant. Always. Of course. And loved the sign off, for the hangman.

Secondly, I was interrupted part way through by [family life]. On my return, picking up part way through, it seemed as though a full beam was being described to me, the deepest of beams and the corresponding flow of sweat.

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Hahaha, ah maybe someday to rewrite this section as a beam description.

Thanks so much mate.

Expand full comment
Ben Wakeman's avatar

This one went a different way than I expected but then you are so good at that. It reminded me of this short story that made a huge impression on me in 5th grade. An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridgehttps://g.co/kgs/kw1hNi1

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Thanks, Ben! Whilst the title rings a bell, I must admit I'm not familiar with the actual work. I'm just reading the wiki page now and it has me definitely intrigued. "and is known for its irregular time sequence and twist ending. Bierce's abandonment of strict linear narration in favor of the internal mind of the protagonist is an early example of the stream of consciousness narrative mode." 👍👍

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

Frankly, the wikipedia explanation strikes me as a load of self-aggrandizing hogwash. Just read the original, Nathan. It's a masterful story, masterfully told: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/375/375-h/375-h.htm

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

Thanks!

Expand full comment
Nathan Slake's avatar

PS having just been catching up on comments here, I note Terry and Daniel's exchange, which is all about this same story!

https://slake.substack.com/p/the-watcher/comment/95053544

Expand full comment